Broil King vs Weber Grills 2020 Review – Which One Is Better?

When it comes to choosing between Broil King vs Weber most people tend to go with Weber without even thinking because it’s one of the most top-selling brands out there on the market.

However, if you are looking for an alternative to Weber then it would be best to check out Broil King which is another high-quality gas grill that comes with tons of advanced features and specs.

The Weber Genesis II S-435 and Broil King Regal 490 Pro are two of the most popular names in the market. This is why I decided to make a broil king vs weber comparison and share with you my rating of which brand I believe wins in this competition.

So without further ado let’s take a look and see which one is more suitable for you.

Broil King vs Weber

FeaturesWeber Genesis II S-435Broil King Regal 490 Pro
Area844 square inches

695 square inches
ColorsStainless SteelBlack Porcelain
Weight176 pounds189.5 pounds
Heat Output69,000 BTU75,000 BTU
PriceCheck PriceCheck Price

Weber Genesis II S-435 – Most Popular Brand

broil king vs weber
View On Amazon

The best selling brand among grills really doesn’t need an introduction. The Weber Genesis II S-435 is the company’s latest launch that comes with four burners, a Sear Station and a side burner.

These burners are made out of stainless steel and are capable of delivering up to 48,000 BTU/hour total heating capacity. This means you will get 74 BTU of heat per hour per square inch of heating space. On the other hand, this device also has a sear station burner that has a total heating capacity of 12,000 BTUs.

This amazing gas grill comes with a 646 square inches of primary cooking area with an additional 198 square inches that constitute a warming rack. This model is also compatible with the iGrill 3 app that gives you the ability to monitor the temperature from mobile devices. The disadvantage is that you’ve to purchase the accessory separately.


Broil King Regal 490 Pro – Better Cooking Power

View On Amazon

Now let us take the time out to look at the main features of this superb quality gas grill. The Broil King Regal 490 Pro is an impressive product that comes with a porcelain-coated cast-iron cooking grate, not the stainless steel. Like Weber Genesis II S-435, this product also has 4 gas burners which are considered to be a bit more powerful than its competitor, along with side and rotisserie burner as well. The side and rotisserie burners are set separately in different cabinets.

The 4 burners of this amazing product are made of dual tube stainless steel and are capable of providing up to 12,250 BTU per hour. With that being said, the rotisserie burner has a heating capacity of 15,000 BTU and the side burner is 10,000 BTU. In terms of the cooking area, the total space is 695 square inches with 500 square inches of primary cooking area.


Comparison Between Broil King and Weber

Burners and Power

Broil King Regal 490 Pro and Weber Genesis II S-435 are both 4 gas burner grills. They are both made with stainless steel and have the ability to provide heat with great consistency.

When it comes to the cooking power, the main burners of Weber Genesis II S-435 have a total heat capacity of 48,000 BTU with 12,000 BTU of the side burner and 9000 BTU for the sear station. On the other hand, the Broil King Regal 490 Pro is a bit ahead in terms of power with a total amount of 50,000 BTU heating capacity with 15,000 BTU for the rotisserie burner and 10,000 BTU for the side burner.

So if your goal is to invest in a gas grill with massive power, then your best bet would be to get yourself a Broil King. There is a total difference of 6,000 BTU of heat capacity.

Cooking Space

This is a very important factor that all buyers will need to take into consideration before buying a gas grill for their backyard. And because buying a gas grill is a one-time investment it’s not a good idea to settle for average.

Considering the cooking space of both products, the Weber Genesis II S-435 offers a total cooking space of 844 square inches. Of this area, the primary cooking space consists of 646 square inches. Whereas, the Broil King Regal 490 Pro has a total cooking area of 695 square inches with a primary cooking space of 500 square inches which is already beaten by the Weber gas grill.

Caster Wheels

Another advantage that the Broil King Regal 490 Pro has over the Weber Genesis II S-435 is the fact that it comes with 4 gliding caster wheels while the Weber only has 2. However, the most important thing is that both products offer locking mechanisms in case you want to take your gas grill somewhere else.

Final Verdict

It’s pretty hard to choose between each product, as this would not be fair at all. Both products have their own unique features. While one product may be good in one category, the other may be better in another.

This is why I think the best idea would be for you to read the comparison carefully and go with the one that best suits your needs. As far as the quality of each product goes, both company’s are the best in the market, they even offer great customer support and service.

You should leave a comment down below letting us know which one you will be going for.

Related Buyers Guide:

Frequently Asked Questions
Do you need to flip a steak when broiling?

Yes, broilers are just inverted grills.

You want to get the crust on both sides of the steak. So you flip it once the side has reach your desired crust level. There is more to it, since distance from the broiler will alter how fast the crust forms and how much the steak cooks.

It’s a balancing act to get the crust and proper doneness you want. If you have the crust and it’s not at the correct doneness you can finish the steak on roast, or keep flipping it and getting it to your desired internal temperature. You want to pull it off 10-20 degrees Fahrenheit before it’s at the desired temperature and then let the steak rest for 5+ minutes.

Broiling the ingredients in the oven vs chopping fresh what s the difference?

It's a different taste and texture...

I roast/broil the tomatoes, peppers, onions and garlic.

The high heat breaks down the fibers and carmelizes the sugars in the veggies. If you char the veggies you also get a nice smoky flavor.

If you char the veggies enough you might end up with something almost black in color like this one:


Edit: added link to previous salsa

Have broilking users figured out the rust issue with the grills?

Man, if I was spending that much I would just buy a Weber. If you’re in the states hit up your local Walmart’s. Walmart locations everywhere have been randomly clearencing old inventory of Weber Genesis and Spirit gas grills (all Weber products actually). Three burner Weber gas grills for like $300.

How to keep sauce from burning while broiling baking salmon?

Put the fish on a rack in a baking pan with some water in the bottom. The excess glaze will drip into the water and won't burn.

One thought on “Broil King vs Weber Grills 2020 Review – Which One Is Better?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *